You are currently viewing The Right To Counsel

The Right To Counsel

The Sixth Amendment of the United States Constitution guarantees the right to counsel for individuals charged with felonies, individuals charged with a misdemeanor and facing the threat of incarceration, and individuals charged with a misdemeanor and facing a suspended sentence. Notably, the Sixth Amendment right to counsel is not guaranteed if there is no threat of the imposition of jail time. The Sixth Amendment was not always guaranteed. Over the last 70 years, this right has been litigated numerous times in the Supreme Court. 

Gideon V. Wainright

In 1963, the Supreme Court decided Gideon v. Wainwright. There, the Court held that the defendants who cannot afford an attorney have the right to have one appointed to them. As the years went on, it was unclear whether this right would apply to all cases (misdemeanor or felony). Because state constitutions varied, a defendant in one state would not be provided with counsel for a given crime even though they would be appointed counsel in another for the same crime. In 1972, the Supreme Court faced the issue – to what types of crimes does the right to counsel apply to? The Supreme Court then established that the right to counsel applied to defendants who committed misdemeanor offenses and faced the threat of incarceration. 

Once more in 1979, the Supreme Court was faced with determining whether the right to counsel applied. This time, the Court held that the right to counsel is not guaranteed in a situation where a defendant is charged with a misdemeanor and is not faced with the threat of imprisonment (i.e., only facing the payment of a fine). 

What Are The exceptions?

Importantly, the right to counsel does not generally extend to post-conviction or sentencing hearings. A lawyer, such as a trusted accident lawyer, knows that the one exception is an uneducated defendant. The Supreme Court has held that in a revocation hearing with an uneducated defendant, the need for counsel will be determined on a case-by-case basis depending on the legal complexity of the appellate issue and whether fundamental fairness demands that the probationer be given assistance. 

Similar to post-conviction, the right to counsel does not apply in all circumstances pre-trial. In Rothgery v. Gillespie County, the Supreme Court held that the right to counsel attaches during critical stages of the prosecutorial process. This means that a defendant’s right to counsel attaches at the commencement of adversarial judicial proceedings. 

What does appointed mean? Do defendants who can’t afford an attorney get their own pick of the litter? Generally, no. The right to counsel of choice does not extend to indigent defendants. When it comes to hiring a private attorney, a defendant has the right to their counsel of choice. Importantly, the right to counsel is only guaranteed in criminal cases. It does not extend to civil matters. 

Getting Representation For Your Case

Thanks to Eglet Adams for their insight on the Sixth Amendment’s right to counsel. The Sixth Amendment’s right to counsel is a cornerstone of the U.S. legal system, assuring representation for many individuals facing charges. While exceptions exist, the pivotal role of legal representation cannot be overstated. In this critical process, securing competent legal counsel is vital for a fair and just legal outcome. To learn more about securing legal counsel, get in touch with a law firm that can help with your needs.